Quote:
Originally Posted by JF2381
Welcome to reeferscafe.com.
Is the tank reef ready? By your description I would assume no.
What kind of skimmer?
What type of corals do you plan on keeping? Our answers will depend on the answer to this question.
First thing I would do is get rid of the canister, nitrate factory in the long run and get 2 overflow box (if drilling is not an option) and setup a sump.
|
For the most part I agree, except for the "first thing".... and that is a gotcha!
Canisters are a double edge sword! I've used them for years in fw and brackish, and use them now in reef and have GREAT luck with them..... lets get to the other edge shall we....
in any environment if you dont clean the canister REGULARILY... your hosed.... clean the thing....
in reef environments the biological section of the canister becomes more of a PROBLEM than help... get rid of it!!! I replaced the bio section of my rena with a bag of phosphate sponge, I clean my canister every two weeks, in fact i use it as a quickie extra 2 gallon water change!..... it's all sponge filter with exception of a bag of carbon and a bag of phosphate remover now!! It's become my greatest ally as the flow and options (spray bar, easy movement and cleanup, etc) as well as the extra mechanical filtration has helped immensely...
but I cant stress it enough, I clean it every other week.. in fact quite often I clean it once a week just because I see it and know what it can cause if I let it go!
canisters are great, it's been amazing at mechanical filtration and I attribute a great deal of success to my use of the thing... but if I didnt maintain it constantly I'd probably be blaming it for my biggest failure as well.
if your up for the maintenance and can keep an eye on it, keep it... if you want to go el natural and let the tank do the work, keeping it would be a disservice to yourself... simply put.
and if you keep it, an added hint... pick up a second set of media, that way when you change you can just swap, run the old media through the dishwasher (no soap and no wet/dry cycle) or rinse it out in the sink when you have time... goes a long way... and DEFINATELY remove the bio media! it's great for mechanical and chemical ONLY... a lot of people recommend adding live rock and still cleaning it and all I can say is cleaning it removes the idea of biological. so why waste the LR, put it in the sump where it's needed.
Canisters are great
Canisters are terrible
it all depends on how you can wield a double edge sword!